So, I've mentally committed myself to buying a "real" tri bike. When I did my first race back in '05, I rode an old used Cannondale I bought from a friend for a couple-hundred dollars. It got me through the first season. I was pretty hooked on tri from the beginning, so when I was getting ready to gear up for Ironman in '07, I wanted to get a new bike. As I went through the process, I couldn't decide between a road bike and a true tri bike. I ended up going with a Kestrel Talon, which seemed to provide a good balance and some versatility. I could put some clip-ons on their and use it for long training rides in the hills around here and still race on it.
The Talon did just fine for Ironman Wisconsin in '07; my bike split wasn't fast by any means, but the bike got the job done. For the '08 season, I wanted to really improve my biking and see if I liked an aero setup so I switched it over to a full-on aero setup with a profile design base bar, profile clip-ons, and bar-end shifters. I worked pretty hard on my biking and did a lot more intensity and intervals. It paid off at Vineman 70.3 '08 where I cut 17 minutes off my bike split from the previous year. I was pretty happy about that and it's what's launched me into my new level of addiction for the sport. Now, I don't feel like a decent runner just getting by on the bike and in the water. Now I'm starting to feel like a tri-athlete and just might be able to start getting close to competing in my age group (not winning, but maybe top 10-15% would be a nice start).
Unfortunately, my new level of addiction means I am ready for a road bike AND a tri bike. My plan is to turn the Talon back into a road bike and put the "regular" bars back on and start shopping for a tri bike. To that end, I spent some quality time at
Davis Wheelworks this weekend. I called them earlier in the week and asked them about the best process to go through to get a good tri bike that was the right fit for me. The person I was talking to then told me he should put me on the phone with "somebody who knows more." So I explained to the new guy on the other end of the line what my deal was and he walked me through what he thought was the best process. He suggested I come in for a preliminary fit and they would proceed to set-up several different rides for me to test ride. And not just 5 minute spins around the block. Full-on rides in shorts, jersey, shoes, etc. for ~20-30 minutes each bike. He also suggested I ride as many as I can in one day to get a good viable comparison. If I spread them out too much, then they would all feel good.
So, I got clearance from my incredibly supportive and loving wife and set off to Davis for my Saturday appointment. When I showed up, they had the first bike on the trainer and ready to go. And it turns out, the guy I talked to on the phone was the owner, Joe Santos. In the first hour, he spent quite a lot of time listening to me describe what I was looking for and getting the first initial fit done so we could "normalize" all the test bikes to the same points in space. He also spent a fair amount of time with me going over all sorts of details about the options, particularly on the wheels. He reviewed some performance data with me on the wheels and explained the difference between the Zipp design and the Hed design. He also talked to me about my plans for the PowerTap and completely understood my dillemma. His suggestion was basically what I was thinking; that it's not good if you train with it, but then don't race with it. So if I got race wheels, I really should go with a PowerTap if I can. Granted, it will be pricey, but this is really the point in training AND racing with power to get the full use out of it.
Felt B12So after all the fitting and discussion, I set out on my first test ride, a Felt B12. This is the middle of the line bike for Felt, below the DA and B2, but higher than the B16 or S32. It was really interesting to feel the difference between a "real" aero position and the normal position on my Talon, which as it turns out, is not perfect (more on that later). So I set out to do the out and back loop they suggested. I went through town, past the Mondavi center, and out to the country rode. I got down in the aero bars and stayed there for the length of the out and back route. It felt pretty darn good, a very stable and powerful feel. I wasn't a huge fan of the saddle we put on there - a Specialized tri saddle, but otherwise, this bike felt pretty good. The fit may need some tuning, but good overall.
Cervelo P2C My next test ride was a Cervelo P2C. Joe set it up on the trainer and we dialed it in based on my basic points in space from teh fit. I felt really comfortable on this bike. He put a Profile Design saddle on it, which I really liked. Much more comfortable than the Specialized saddle in my humble opinion. So I proceeded back out on the route, through campus, past Mondavi, out to the country. When I got out on the road on this bike, the fit felt good, but I have to say, the handling felt a little too responsive and almost twitchy... much different than the Felt. Joe said he gets mixed opinions on the Felt vs. the Cervelo on how they handle. Some say Cervelo is more stable, some say Felt. For me, it was the Felt.
Kuota Kaliber When I got back, Joe had set up the Kuota Kaliber. This bike has a more slack geometry and less steep effective seat tube angle. And boy could I feel the difference. It definitely compressed my hip angle when in the aero position. I gave it a chance, though, and went out on the ride. Definitely much less comfortable in the aero position.
Scott Plasma Joe said this bike also has a little less seat tube angle, but he set it up as best he could for me. When I hit the road on this bike, it felt great! I really liked it. It had a Fizik saddle on it and I think the Profile Design saddle is more comfortable, but that wasn't too bad. The one thing I didn't like on this bike was the aero bars were too close together and cramped my arms together too much. Not a problem that can't be overcome. The real issue with this bike is the wheels. It is an '08 limited and comes with 808 tubulars. I don't want to mess with tubulars. I might be able to sell the wheels and get some clinchers (with the PowerTap), but I'm not sure I want to go through that hassle. Otherwise, this was a great bike.

After I finished all the test rides, Joe put together the prices for me so I could mull things over. Not only that, when I got home later that night, he had prepared a PDF with a picture of each bike, the relevant specs, prices, and notes from my test ride. Pretty impressive. If anybody is looking for a place to get a tri bike, I would have to recommend Davis Wheelworks. Good choices and great service.
Now, back to the Talon... the next day, I did my prescribed 2.5 hour ride and now that I can ride for short stints in my aero bars, even with the PowerCranks, I got a good comparison between the fit on my Talon and the aero fit on the other bikes I tried. The Talon felt almost exactly the same as the Kalibur. Definitely not a good fit for me. Didn't fell nearly as powerful (not that I'm all that powerful on the bike to begin with, so I need all the help I can get!) Just more evidence that I need to set that bike up as a road bike for training and get a better tri bike. Even though I'm still struggling a bit with the cost, especially for good race wheels, I am more sure now that it will help me in the long run and achieving my rather lofty goals.
The next step is to go back when they receive the '09 Felt bikes so I can give an '09 B2 a try. I am a little concerned about some stuff I've been reading about the bayonnet system on those bikes, but Joe S. doesn't think it's a problem if you get it set up right to begin with. We'll see how it feels.
To be continued after the next set of test rides...